Starboard Commercial Real Estate

Hans Hansson | February 16, 2012

Just before the holidays I toured a client who was looking for 3,000 square feet of office space around the financial district in San Francisco. We were looking into more of the Class B type buildings and toured four buildings that made our short list; on average the price per square foot was in the mid thirties. My client indicated that with the holidays coming up, he wanted to hold off on making any final decisions on a new space until after the first of the year. Last week we toured the same buildings again only to find that the very same spaces were now going for high thirties to low forties in rent. What happened in three weeks?

Both the San Francisco Chronicle and the San Francisco Business Times ran articles discussing how the city is running out of commercial space in South of Market and how the market has tightened in the core financial districts all due to our new tech boom. Once these articles hit the streets, building owners were raising prices the very next day.

Today, core financial district and close-in South of Market locations are looking at a vacancy rate currently at or below five percent; this is not good for landlords or tenants in the long run. To understand why a five percent vacancy is in fact a threat, one must first understand how buildings are financed. When a building is financed it is never given credit for being one hundred percent leased. There is always a five percent vacancy factor that is customary to be taken into account in the value determination for an office building. Once a building hits ninety-five percent occupancy or less, the building owner no longer has any incentive to lease out the remaining building by being more competitive in rents. In fact, since there is no financial incentive to rent this space, in terms of seeking higher financing options it is better to seek the highest rents possible and hold firm on that price even though the remaining space may never lease at that rental rate.

Building are valued most often by the last deal done in the building. Using my tenant as an example; if he were to accept a low forties rental rate the building would be looked upon more favorably since the rental rate for the entire building would be in the forties against the overall average for the rest of the building which may be in the twenties or low thirties. Building owners would be well positioned with added value for their buildings because as spaces become available, their lenders would anticipate those rents at the new high rental rate mark. The problem with this logic is that building owners today are dealing in a market place that is based upon a growth sector (tech) that, as a whole, is not profitable. The technology sector is made up of start-up companies seeking to gain acceptance and profitability but the realty is the majority of these firms will not make it.

Another hard truth is that conventional businesses, like the rest of the country, are now at best stabilized from the effect of this long recession. Most businesses are still short of cash and are not seeing anywhere near the growth needed to pay twenty to forty percent more in rent. This was clear to me on the tour mentioned above when I went to a building to tour five spaces: four of these spaces still had businesses in place. In the past it was rare to tour a building with the majority of the spaces still occupied; this only happens in a tight market. My guess is that these businesses were nearing the end of a typical five year commitment in a building that had original rental rates in the mid to high twenties. Now, with building owners notifying their tenants that renewal rates will be in the high thirties or forties, tenants simply cannot afford the rent.

Overall, the ripple effect of a five percent vacancy creates an uncertain future for businesses and business owners who, in all reality, stand more of a chance for longevity than the current up cropping of start-ups. Building owners will soon awake to the slowing of the tech boom and the reality that real rental rates are nowhere the prices that they are now quoting. As business people and residents of San Francisco, we have to ask the question of whether this current situation will be detrimental in the long run to our city and economy.
Posted 7 years, 6 months ago on February 16, 2012
The trackback url for this post is

Comments on this post:

Re: The Threat of a Five Percent Office Vacancy
Great analysis of the current trend and potential impacts. Will this start a new construction boon in office buildings south of Market, or will start-ups elect to move out of the financial district to less expensive areas that can also accommodate growth?

2012/02/16 by scott adams • • Reply
Comment Trackback URL :
Re: The Threat of a Five Percent Office Vacancy
A boom no but the addition of several new projects yes. Also will jump start some Residential condo project that have been stalled

2012/02/20 by Anonymous • • Reply
Comment Trackback URL :
Re: The Threat of a Five Percent Office Vacancy
Great overview of what has happened in San Francisco recently.
The longevity of some of the stabel tenants creates a void for services that will be missed.

2012/02/21 by Frank Vella wwwReply
Comment Trackback URL :
Re: The Threat of a Five Percent Office Vacancy
I comment each time I like a article on a site or if I have something to contribute to
the discussion. Usually it is a result of the passion displayed in the post I browsed.
And on this article The Threat of a Five Percent Office Vacancy - Starboard TCN Worldwide Commercial Real Estate. I was actually excited enough to post a thought :
-P I actually do have a couple of questions for you if it's allright. Is it only me or do a few of the remarks come across as if they are left by brain dead individuals? :-P And, if you are posting at other online sites, I would like to follow you. Could you list all of your community sites like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?

2012/05/16 by find mcallen homes for sale • • Reply
Comment Trackback URL :
Re: The Threat of a Five Percent Office Vacancy
We have a number of sites which the same articles are posted. Yes you can find us under Starboard TCN Worldwide or myself Hans Hansson at Facebook, Linkedin and Twitter plus our You Tube Channel

2012/06/06 by Hans Hansson • • Reply
Comment Trackback URL :

Comments have now been turned off for this post

Real Estate Blog Top Sites Blog Flux Directory  Real Estate blogs   Top Blogs
Credits: ©2019 by Starboard TCN Worldwide Commercial Real Estate
Powered by bBlog | template by Starboard Commercial Real Estate, inspired by dmig